Try every version of a line before you pick one
Start from a feeling or an image, give each section of the song its own branch, and keep every alternative line until you choose.
See it in action
One line about a lighthouse keeper developed into verses, a chorus and a song structure.
How it works
Start with a feeling, an image or a line you cannot shake. Each section of the song gets its own branch, and the alternatives for each line sit side by side.
-
Start with the seed. Ask what the idea is about underneath and how the feeling could move from the first verse to the last chorus.
-
Lay out the structure. Add a branch per section: verse, pre-chorus, chorus, bridge and outro. Give each one a job, such as setting the scene or breaking the pattern.
-
Try alternatives. Under any line, ask for three or four versions, such as a concrete image in place of a metaphor, an internal rhyme or a shorter phrase. All of them stay on the map until you choose.
-
Note the sound. Add notes with musical ideas next to the lyrics, such as sparse instruments for a lonely verse or a key change into the last chorus.
Why branches suit songwriting
Songwriters write more than they keep, and when you write top to bottom, the first version of a line tends to stay. On the map, the simple version you branched away from is still there. You can see when it serves the chorus better than the clever one.
Example
Say you are writing a breakup song about relief mixed with guilt. One branch collects images of relief: open windows, cooking for one and liking it. Another collects guilt: a toothbrush still in the holder, a voicemail you have not deleted. A third tries chorus lines, such as “The quiet isn’t lonely anymore.” Reading the two image branches side by side tells you the chorus should hold both feelings.