Keep competing hypotheses side by side
Give each explanation its own branch, ask what supports it and what would falsify it, and find the predictions that tell them apart.
See it in action
A map of why insect pollinators are declining, built hypothesis by hypothesis with the evidence and falsifiers for each.
How it works
Enter the thing you want to explain and the model proposes several hypotheses. Each one gets its own branch, and every question under it keeps that hypothesis in context.
-
State the question. Describe the phenomenon. Ask for plausible explanations drawn from established theory and recent findings.
-
Give each hypothesis a branch. Under each one, ask what it assumes, what evidence supports it, and what would falsify it.
-
Find the predictions that differ. Ask under the list of hypotheses, which names them all, where they predict different results. Branch into the experiments or datasets that would test each difference.
-
Check for overlap. Ask whether two hypotheses could both hold at different scales or over different time frames. Some pairs turn out to be compatible, and the rest are the real conflicts to test.
Why a map instead of linear notes
Once you favor one explanation, it is easy to read every result through it. With three hypotheses on the map, each with its own evidence and gaps, the alternatives stay in front of you.
Expanding a hypothesis also shows what it contains. Under phenological mismatch, sub-branches for temperature, day length and rainfall each need different data, so one hypothesis becomes several claims to test.
Example
Say you are investigating why a gene therapy works better in some patients than in others. The map branches into genetic differences in drug response, immune response, and how well the delivery vector reaches the target tissue. Under immune response you split pre-existing antibodies from T-cell clearance. The T-cell branch shows that the trials you have read control for antibodies but not for T-cell responses, and that gap becomes your next study.